Download a copy of the Historic Registry application.
| Number | Residence | Name | Address | City/State | Approval Date | Year |
| 1 | Joseph Bouton Residence | Nathan & Linda Muller | 707 West Main Street | Smethport, PA 16749 | Spring 2007 | 1905 |
| 2 | C.D. Comes Residence | Judge and Mrs. Yoder | 608 W. King Street | Smethport, PA 16749 | Spring 2007 | 1900 |
| 3 | Cottage House | Mike and Connie Kandare | 202 Fulton Street | Smethport, PA 16749 | Spring 2007 | 1899 |
| 4 | Defilippi Residence | Carl A. and Mary Jane Defilippi | 402 W. Green Street | Smethport, PA 16749 | Spring 2007 | 1877 |
| 5 | St. Elizabeth of Hungary Church | Congregation of St. Elizabeth of Hungary | Main and Franklin Street | Smethport, PA 16749 | Spring 2007 | 1906 |
| 6 | Forrest Residence | George and Debbie Tufts | 602 W. Main Street | Smethport, PA 16749 | Spring 2007 | 1880 |
| 7 | Grange National Bank | Northwest Savings Bank | 428 W. Main Street | Smethport, PA 16749 | Spring 2007 | 1907 |
| 8 | H.H. Redfield Mansion | Sean and Nancy O’Day | 703 W. Main Street | Smethport, PA 16749 | Spring 2007 | 1903 |
| 9 | Hamilton Building | Yuletide Properties | 519 E. Mill Street | Smethport, PA 16749 | Spring 2007 | 1903 |
| 10 | Masonic Lodge | c/o: Troy M. Herzog | 601 W. Main Street | Smethport, PA 16749 | Spring 2007 | 1922 |
| 11 | S.D. Freeman Residence | c/o: Anthony J. Alfieri | 17 Rosehill Avenue | Smethport, PA 16749 | Spring 2007 | 1895? |
| 12 | St. Luke’s Episcopal Church | c/o: Reverend John Wesley | 602 W. Main Street | Smethport, PA 16749 | Spring 2007 | 1891 |
| 13 | William Specht Residence | Warren E. Semmel and Bonnie L. Semmel | 307 S. Mechanic Street | Smethport, PA 16749 | Spring 2007 | 1865 |
| 14 | Upper Tavern | Reid and Cynthia Matteson | 407 Church Street | Smethport, PA 16749 | Spring 2007 | 1830 |
| 15 | John Nevin Apple Mansion | Jeanne O. Romine | 802 W. King Street | Smethport, PA 16749 | 3/28/2007 | 1872 |
| 16 | McCandless Residence | Ross and Jovanna Porter | 905 W. Main Street | Smethport, PA 16749 | Spring 2007 | 1891 |
| 17 | Trinity Lutheran Church | Congregation of Trinity Luthern Church | Fulton Street | Smethport, PA 16749 | 3/28/2007 | 1879 |
| 18 | The Clark Building | Harold Lindgren | 311 W. Main Street | Smethport, PA 16749 | 9/1/2007 | 1899 |
| 19 | The Ralph Burdick Mansion | William Todd | 1001 W. Main Street | Smethport, PA 16749 | 9/1/2007 | 1900 |
| 20 | Smethport Diner | Connie Ronan | 433 W. Main Street | Smethport, PA 16749 | Spring 2007 | 1937 |
| 21 | Robert King Residence | Graham and Carol Nannen | 110 W. Main Street | Smethport, PA 16749 | Spring 2007 | 1859 |
| 22 | Leonard B Johnson Residence | Brian Gustafson | 1235 W. Main Street | Smethport, PA 16749 | 1936 | |
| 23 | Charles McKean Mansion | Brian Gustafson | 102 W. Main Street | Smethport, PA 16749 | December 2007 | 1904 |
| 24 | Smethport Print Shop | Olson Tenglund | 304 Fulton Street | Smethport, PA 16749 | December 2007 | 1912 |
| 25 | F.D. Gallup Mansion | Anne Potter | 306 W. Green Street | Smethport, PA 16749 | 1/7/2008 | 1902 |
| 26 | W.D. Gallup Mansion | Anne Potter | 302/304 W. Green Street | Smethport, PA 16749 | 1/7/2008 | 1880 |
| 27 | Byron Hamlin Mansion | Ernie and Pat Long | 619 W. Main Street | Smethport, PA 16749 | 1/7/2008 | 1856 |
| 28 | Delano R. Hamlin Mansion | Shaun & Judy King | 820 W. Main Street | Smethport, PA 16749 | 1/7/2008 | 1881 |
| 29 | JC Backus Residence | Ryan Yingling | Smethport, PA 16749 | 1/7/2008 | 1825 | |
| 30 | United Methodist Church | Church & King Streets | Smethport, PA 16749 | July 2008 | 1837 | |
| 31 | Purtle Blacksmih Shop | 405-407 W. Water Street | Smethport, PA 16749 | July 2008 | 1892 |
